A preserved archive of the Logical Gamers community forums, 2009-2025. The original threads and posts, served read-only. Registration, posting and private messages are gone for good.

Man 'killed wife during a dream'

1.1k views · started by Administrator ·
#1
Man 'killed wife during a dream'
The trial of a husband accused of murdering his wife as they slept in a camper van has heard he killed her because he dreamt she was an intruder.

The body of Christine Thomas, 57, was found in a camper van in a car park in Aberporth, Ceredigion, in July 2008.

Swansea Crown Court heard that her husband Brian Thomas, 59, suffered from a sleep disorder.

The prosecution says it is seeking a verdict of "not guilty by reason of insanity" against Mr Thomas, of Neath.

Prosecuting barrister Paul Thomas QC, in his opening words to the jury on Tuesday morning, described the case as "highly unusual".

He described how Mr Thomas killed his wife, his childhood sweetheart, because he had dreamt she was a man who had broken into their motor home.

The court was told Mr Thomas's disorder meant he was not in control of his actions when he strangled his partner of 40 years.

After commissioning evidence from sleep experts, the prosecution agreed his actions were involuntary and he could not be held responsible.

The prosecution has told the jury it will have a choice between the "not guilty by reason of insanity" verdict it would argue for, or the straightforward "not guilty" verdict the defence would seek.

The case continues.
#2
Holy crap 40 years!
That's facked... :(
#3
wow that sucks well i hope he diddnt do it on purpose thats a unusual case..
#4
Awww that's so sad. The guy must have been mortified when he woke up and found her like that.
#5
I say he's bullshitting around. People will say literally anything to get off. Honestly, it's the same as "God told me to in a dream" or some other bullshit excuse, the end result being his wife dead, and her blood on his hands.
#6
That had to of sucked when he woke up and found her dead =/
#7
Wow, i wish i could do that. xP
But not in america, i'll die in prison there. -.-
#8
Weird. I believe that counts as manslaughter, not insanity.
#9
He shouldn't be left on his own anymore so pushing the basic "not guilty" verdict would be a bad idea. Stick that dude in a ward till the problem is eradicated or taken control of.
#10
Shojo wrote:
That's just horrible. I would want to go to jail if I did that.

Not sure about wanting to go to jail, but I'd obviously want help. Or perhaps death.
#11
Wow... think of how the man is coping through this. He must have the biggest cloud of guilt and sorrow over him.
#12
What proof is there he was asleep? How do you know he isn't just faking the whole thing?
#13
That's so sad...
#14
C0FFINCASE wrote:
What proof is there he was asleep? How do you know he isn't just faking the whole thing?


What proof do you have that he wasn't asleep?

I'm pretty sure for it to come down to those 2 verdicts that there was a lot of analyzing of the subject. They don't just go up to the guy and say, so you killed your wife? YES! I DID IT IN MY SLEEP! Ok, good enough for us.

But it all boils down to: you never know what a person has truly done just by looking at the evidence.
#15
well it was not his fault. although he should grt due to insanity
#16
wow really if you had to live with that it would suck if he wasn't lieing.....
#17
holy damn lol that is messed =/
#18
Watch in a month he commits suciucide due to guilt and or confusion.
#19
IMO this is such bs. He definitely did it on purpose, there is no way he could sleep kill his wife. She could have definitely slapped him awake or something before she died...
Sad story though, I feel bad for the woman.
#20
Bunch of shit, he killed her on purpose.
#21
Thats weird... To have a dream and doing it the same time
#22
Damn that is crazy
#23
That 'not guilty because of insanity' is just complete crap. He killed someone, that's that. Insanity's too hard of a thing to judge in our society nowadays.
[/color]
#24
Thats ridicoulous..no more sleepovers for me...How can you kill someone while asleep...