A preserved archive of the Logical Gamers community forums, 2009-2025. The original threads and posts, served read-only. Registration, posting and private messages are gone for good.

SOTW #2 Voting

2.5k views · started by Eli · · closed · page 1 of 2
#1
SOTW #2 Voting
Only two choices this week.


Minora


Xoom

Please vote upon how well the theme is followed, and how well the signature is executed.
#2
Lol@ not using the right names.
#3
My vote goes to Sam. Don't really have a reason. Both are great.
#4
gotxbrain wrote:
Lol@ not using the right names.


Lol@ not realizing no one really cares about your name change or his.


Anyways.
I chose Xoom's because it's just visually better.
Great flow, great color scheme. Perfect font + font effect for the signature. Overall just a awesome sig.

Minora's has like no flow, it's a couple of c4d's, and a car put on a grungey background. With I'm guessing some splatter brushes set on a lower opacity for a different effect. I dunno if I'm wrong about that. But in general it isn't really visually appealing.
#5
Considering we are very dead.
I'm going to be using very popular themes from now on.

It will give you guys something to work with.
#6
Eli wrote:
Considering we are very dead.
I'm going to be using very popular themes from now on.

It will give you guys something to work with.


Xoom's sig discouraged me to continue making mine..:shout:
#7
Make the sigs :
Movies, Cartoons, or even make it look at only 1 character to see who does that one the best.
#8
Martin wrote:
Xoom's sig discouraged me to continue making mine..:shout:


Im sorry i had to step up my game
Just because Saved And Eli was about to join xD
#9
Why you guys going with Xoom? the top one is way better it has more detailed sparkle :)
#10
M0NST3R wrote:
Why you guys going with Xoom? the top one is way better it has more detailed sparkle :)


Words of someone who's never done gfx
#11
Martin wrote:
Words of someone who's never done gfx


Yes this is true...........
#12
Honestly, I think xoom cheated. All it is is a stock with a few colored lines
#13
Eli wrote:
Considering we are very dead.
I'm going to be using very popular themes from now on.

It will give you guys something to work with.


Can't wait to see what you've got in mind! If theme appeals to me I'll definitely join in.

---------- Post added at 07:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:24 PM ----------

gotxbrain wrote:
Honestly, I think xoom cheated. All it is is a stock with a few colored lines


you could've done 10x better on yours. Just saying
#14
gotxbrain wrote:
Honestly, I think xoom cheated. All it is is a stock with a few colored lines


Stocks can be used in sigs...
You just dont have proper gimp/photoshop skills
Try using effects for once

And trust me it isnt as simple as it looks
#15
Sam wrote:
Stocks can be used in sigs...
You just dont have proper gimp/photoshop skills
Try using effects for once

And trust me it isnt as simple as it looks


agree, but just so we don't have to deal with stocks. Eli, you should have people enter, and you give them one render to work with. No stocks. I think it would be fun to see how people manipulate a render to great flow and an all around good sig. I will definitely partake.
#16
If its only 1 person giving out renders
It would eliminate the fact we cant make what we want
Besides its the theme that matters
Also stocks aren't a big deal unless you know what your doing
Along with some effects BOOM there you go
#17
Sam wrote:
If its only 1 person giving out renders
It would eliminate the fact we cant make what we want
Besides its the theme that matters
Also stocks aren't a big deal unless you know what your doing
Along with some effects BOOM there you go


makes it easy peasy. I want a challenge.
#18
Then that challenge is up to you
The challenge mainly is what you can make with whatever you got
#19
I'd like to see more people enter, mainly because we are so dead.
More tutorials made etc.

I have quite a bit of school crap right now, so I can't be as active as I'd like.
When summer comes around everything will hopefully pick back up again.

---------- Post added at 07:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:39 PM ----------

Mx250z wrote:
agree, but just so we don't have to deal with stocks. Eli, you should have people enter, and you give them one render to work with. No stocks. I think it would be fun to see how people manipulate a render to great flow and an all around good sig. I will definitely partake.


K.
So one render.
I'll render something cool.
I like the idea, however it won't be every week.
And with SOTW just starting up, I'd like to give you guys some time to improve.
#20
I honestly think stock sigs look a lot better. Since it shows more blending in the background and stuff.
#21
Martin wrote:
I honestly think stock sigs look a lot better. Since it shows more blending in the background and stuff.


Not as many capabilities with stock signatures in my eyes.
#22
Why not have both so we have 2 choices
#23
Eli wrote:
Not as many capabilities with stock signatures in my eyes.


I'm just saying I think they look cleaner and better :P
I prefer simplistic work over cluttered things packed with effects and c4d's.
#24
Sam wrote:
Why not have both so we have 2 choices


because the ability to adapt to something not in your favor is a valuable life lesson. Deal with it
#25
gotxbrain wrote:
because the ability to adapt to something not in your favor is a valuable life lesson. Deal with it


I agree.
However most weeks, you guys get to pick.
#26
gotxbrain wrote:
because the ability to adapt to something not in your favor is a valuable life lesson. Deal with it


Then make it your own priority
Because you can't adapt
#27
Sam wrote:
Then that challenge is up to you
The challenge mainly is what you can make with whatever you got


haha alright, I look forward to the next sotw Sam. Its gonna be fun. I usually only use renders though. Cuz I feel its artistically mine. Lol.
#28
Mx250z wrote:
haha alright, I look forward to the next sotw Sam. Its gonna be fun. I usually only use renders though. Cuz I feel its artistically mine. Lol.


I'd love to see what your capable of :3
#29
You guys will both see what I'm capable of.
#30
Eli wrote:
You guys will both see what I'm capable of.


this is gonna be great! Lol, I remember when I'll u did was post funny pics in jy Eli. Times sure have changed
#31
Eli wrote:
You guys will both see what I'm capable of.


Try saving in .png not .jpg/jpeg
*points to your current sig* lol
#32
Mx250z wrote:
this is gonna be great! Lol, I remember when I'll u did was post funny pics in jy Eli. Times sure have changed


You make me blush O3O
That was a long time ago.

---------- Post added at 08:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:10 PM ----------

Martin wrote:
Try saving in .png not .jpg/jpeg
*points to your current sig* lol


Yeah.
I should stop uploading to tinypic.
imageshack or something.
And I'm updating darth.
#33
I upload to photobucket atm
And to a .Png file
#34
Eli wrote:
You make me blush O3O
That was a long time ago.

---------- Post added at 08:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:10 PM ----------



Yeah.
I should stop uploading to tinypic.
imageshack or something.
And I'm updating darth.


DUDE yea it was. I feel ancient :P
#35
Mx250z wrote:
DUDE yea it was. I feel ancient :P


Anyone from back then should.
All of the oldies have died out, the regulars that I'm use to seeing have either
A) Been Banned
B) Rage Quit
C) Dropped from the face of the earth
or
D) Found a life that doesn't involve LG.
#36
I like the overall look of Xoom's.
#37
Eli wrote:
Anyone from back then should.
All of the oldies have died out, the regulars that I'm use to seeing have either
A) Been Banned
B) Rage Quit
C) Dropped from the face of the earth
or
D) Found a life that doesn't involve LG.

yea, it doesn't feel the same. Half these people I don't know. And the activity is horrible. I miss the old people. They're what made it fun.
#38
Eli wrote:
Anyone from back then should.
All of the oldies have died out, the regulars that I'm use to seeing have either
A) Been Banned
B) Rage Quit
C) Dropped from the face of the earth
or
D) Found a life that doesn't involve LG.

I'm an oldie.
I'm just not as known or loved as the other ones.
#39
ITT: Butthurt oldfags
#40
Mx250z wrote:
yea, it doesn't feel the same. Half these people I don't know. And the activity is horrible. I miss the old people. They're what made it fun.


Now it's all Gaia nubs.
And gotxbrain.