A preserved archive of the Logical Gamers community forums, 2009-2025. The original threads and posts, served read-only. Registration, posting and private messages are gone for good.

Sotw Critique for all entrants

719 views · started by Eli ·
#1
Sotw Critique for all entrants
Taz - :eyes on fire:
Tutorials, you need tutorials.

Minora - This is by far, one of my favorite signatures from you.
I did however think that it was a bit to large, and the C4D shouldn't have covered the focal.
The background was a bit odd, however it was perty.

Martin - While I did like it, it was a bit too bright, and should have involved more green in my opinion. The flow ended up going in two directions, however I liked it a lot.

Xoom - There was really no flow to the signature, due to the lightning coming from ichigo's hand, and the background tree thing or whatever was out of place.
However you did have some very nice color coordination, and even though it had its flaws, it looked very bad ass.
#2
Eli wrote:
Taz - :eyes on fire:
Tutorials, you need tutorials.

Minora - This is by far, one of my favorite signatures from you.
I did however think that it was a bit to large, and the C4D shouldn't have covered the focal.
The background was a bit odd, however it was perty.

Martin - While I did like it, it was a bit too bright, and should have involved more green in my opinion. The flow ended up going in two directions, however I liked it a lot.

Xoom - There was really no flow to the signature, due to the lightning coming from ichigo's hand, and the background tree thing or whatever was out of place.
However you did have some very nice color coordination, and even though it had its flaws, it looked very bad ass.


Face made* me lmao
#3
Eli wrote:

Minora - This is by far, one of my favorite signatures from you.
I did however think that it was a bit to large, and the C4D shouldn't have covered the focal.
The background was a bit odd, however it was perty.



It's TOO not TO

Also, it was WAY smaller than a lot of the stuff i'm used to making, how much smaller do I have to get? :/ I could barely get in any detail. Also, I don't use c4ds. I use 3d renders, but i don't use c4ds. Stop calling everything a fucking c4d. c4ds are made in Cinema 4 D.
#4
gotxbrain wrote:
It's TOO not TO

Also, it was WAY smaller than a lot of the stuff i'm used to making, how much smaller do I have to get? :/ I could barely get in any detail. Also, I don't use c4ds. I use 3d renders, but i don't use c4ds. Stop calling everything a fucking c4d. c4ds are made in Cinema 4 D.


It looks like a lightly colored c4d set on lighten.
3d render, c4d, same thing, and or doesn't matter.

@Martin
You have confused me.
#5
Eli wrote:
It looks like a lightly colored c4d set on lighten.
3d render, c4d, same thing, and or doesn't matter.

@Martin
You have confused me.


It's not the same thing, c4d is a term given to a render made with cinema 4d. all C4Ds are 3d Renders, but not all 3d renders are C4Ds
#6
Eli wrote:
It looks like a lightly colored c4d set on lighten.
3d render, c4d, same thing, and or doesn't matter.

@Martin
You have confused me.


Check edit pl0x lol

@Minora - Damn settle down. lol
#7
Yeh The Flow Of It Wasn't Too Good
But It Still Looked Bad Ass But i Will Next Time Spend More Time On My Sigs xD
Most Of Emm Are Like Made In 30-45 Mins My Apologies
#8
I put one of my old sigs i made when i was attempting to make sig on photoshop.
Mine was just to start it off because no one was posting there. :P
#9
And For Lolz Too Right? xD
#10
gotxbrain wrote:
It's not the same thing, c4d is a term given to a render made with cinema 4d. all C4Ds are 3d Renders, but not all 3d renders are C4Ds


Okay, have fun with those 3D renders, jeez.

@Martin
It was the only appropriate face.

@Xoom
I'm entering next week to give you guys' someone to watch out for.
#11
Oh no guys we have competition in our hands
Im gonna make next weeks a bit better ;3
#12
Sam wrote:
Oh no guys we have competition in our hands
Im gonna make next weeks a bit better ;3


Saved is entering as well, at least I think she is.