Come Rate. Gotxbrain.

Yet again I'm trying something very different.
I used only the render, background stock, and chalk and circle brushes for smudging and color.

I don't like it. I was also hoping for some unique typography on my name, not exactly the same thing I did. Thanks anyway.

(Perhaps you should stop 'trying something different')

I like it.

I don't. can you remake it, except this time just make them like you made all the others. don't try something you've never done before :/

gotxbrain wrote:

I don't. can you remake it, except this time just make them like you made all the others. don't try something you've never done before :/

Boring. i

stapled wrote:

Boring. i

Coming from a proffesional standpoint, I would never present a client with an experiment. I'd stick to things I know look good and that people like. I'd save the experimenting for practice, and try to perfect it until it's something i'm cofortable replicating and can make look good.

gotxbrain wrote:

Coming from a proffesional standpoint, I would never present a client with an experiment. I'd stick to things I know look good and that people like. I'd save the experimenting for practice, and try to perfect it until it's something i'm cofortable replicating and can make look good.

stapled wrote:

I like it.

And it looks good to me.

stapled wrote:

And it looks good to me.

then let me correct that.

... know look good and that the client likes.

gotxbrain wrote:

then let me correct that.

:secret laugh: See what I did there?

stapled wrote:

:secret laugh: See what I did there?

<3 .
I actually like it better with that typography.

---------- Post added at 01:10 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:06 AM ----------

gotxbrain wrote:

I don't like it. I was also hoping for some unique typography on my name, not exactly the same thing I did. Thanks anyway.

(Perhaps you should stop 'trying something different')

My request thread is a request thread for a reason.
If you wanted to specify that you wanted unique typography.
You should have said so, or I go by what I want to do.

Eli wrote:

<3 .
I actually like it better with that typography.

---------- Post added at 01:10 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:06 AM ----------



My request thread is a request thread for a reason.
If you wanted to specify that you wanted unique typography.
You should have said so, or I go by what I want to do.

then what you did was copy off of me. I didn't know it was that good.

gotxbrain wrote:

then what you did was copy off of me. I didn't know it was that good.

You said you wanted something similar, and I can quote that.
So I did something smaller, that I believed looked better than large, bold typography.

And I'll have no problem making another, mainly because I'm doing this for practice.
I assume same render?

gotxbrain wrote:

I don't like it. I was also hoping for some unique typography on my name, not exactly the same thing I did. Thanks anyway.

(Perhaps you should stop 'trying something different')

I Don't Like Your Attitude
Why Not Make Your Own "Professional Sig"
Instead Of Requesting

Xoom wrote:

I Don't Like Your Attitude
Why Not Make Your Own "Professional Sig"
Instead Of Requesting

*points to current sig*

If Can't be Satisfied On What You Get
And Can't Make Your Own... Why Do You
Request For Sigs?

gotxbrain wrote:

*points to current sig*

I mean no offense by saying this but, you definitely could use practice, your current skills are that of an amateur.

But hey!
If you believe that you are professional and your work is that great, beauty is in the eye of the beholder correct?

Xoom wrote:

If Can't be Satisfied On What You Get
And Can't Make Your Own... Why Do You
Request For Sigs?

I don't know what you are trying to say. I am satisfied with my current sig, I was looking for something to accompany it. I can make my own, and I did.

Yo xoom, get on MSN.

gotxbrain wrote:

I don't know what you are trying to say. I am satisfied with my current sig, I was looking for something to accompany it. I can make my own, and I did.

Then I Advice You To Make Your
Own Sigs Till It Looks As Good
As The Ones You Requested

Eli wrote:

<3 .
I actually like it better with that typography.

---------- Post added at 01:10 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:06 AM ----------



My request thread is a request thread for a reason.
If you wanted to specify that you wanted unique typography.
You should have said so, or I go by what I want to do.

That's not typography, that's called changing the font.
I'm pretty sure we're not all professionals; we're just amateurs that neglect our own infallibilities. Eli, I suggest if you want people to simply rate, (instead of attacking you) you set up a poll system or ask users to vote on a 1-10 system.

And Minora, I can understand if you're dissatisfied. "I don't like it" Doesn't carry you very far though. If you want everything to be absolute perfection, then be sure to make an extremely detailed request down to the last pixel. For a person who simply crops their signature to make an avatar. You're very detail oriented.

Anyway about the signature:
I'm glad you're experimenting...that's honestly the best way to improve and mature to find styles that work. I suggest playing around with positioning of your render. You seem to always have it dead center. Some of the best selcas I've seen are interesting because the person intentionally cuts off and uses other parts of the photo elsewhere. Also, the brushes look too harsh and just stamped onto the render. I do love the background though. Those different hues of light and dark blend so well together!

Saved wrote:

That's not typography, that's called changing the font.
I'm pretty sure we're not all professionals; we're just amateurs that neglect our own infallibilities. Eli, I suggest if you want people to simply rate, (instead of attacking you) you set up a poll system or ask users to vote on a 1-10 system.

And Minora, I can understand if you're dissatisfied. "I don't like it" Doesn't carry you very far though. If you want everything to be absolute perfection, then be sure to make an extremely detailed request down to the last pixel. For a person who simply crops their signature to make an avatar. You're very detail oriented.

Anyway about the signature:
I'm glad you're experimenting...that's honestly the best way to improve and mature to find styles that work. I suggest playing around with positioning of your render. You seem to always have it dead center. Some of the best selcas I've seen are interesting because the person intentionally cuts off and uses other parts of the photo elsewhere. Also, the brushes look too harsh and just stamped onto the render. I do love the background though. Those different hues of light and dark blend so well together!

I lol'd .

Saved wrote:

That's not typography, that's called changing the font.
I'm pretty sure we're not all professionals; we're just amateurs that neglect our own infallibilities. Eli, I suggest if you want people to simply rate, (instead of attacking you) you set up a poll system or ask users to vote on a 1-10 system.

And Minora, I can understand if you're dissatisfied. "I don't like it" Doesn't carry you very far though. If you want everything to be absolute perfection, then be sure to make an extremely detailed request down to the last pixel. For a person who simply crops their signature to make an avatar. You're very detail oriented.

Anyway about the signature:
I'm glad you're experimenting...that's honestly the best way to improve and mature to find styles that work. I suggest playing around with positioning of your render. You seem to always have it dead center. Some of the best selcas I've seen are interesting because the person intentionally cuts off and uses other parts of the photo elsewhere. Also, the brushes look too harsh and just stamped onto the render. I do love the background though. Those different hues of light and dark blend so well together!

I think of the 1-10 thing every time I look at this thread, however if it doesn't have good critique to back it up then it is worthless to me in the long run, and it doesn't help me improve.
If anything I think I should just PM you the signature, you've given fantastic critique towards my stuff.

And the signature itself, The only thing I really have a problem with is that I didn't do some very simple things that would've made the brushes seem more subtle.

Saved wrote:

And Minora, I can understand if you're dissatisfied. "I don't like it" Doesn't carry you very far though. If you want everything to be absolute perfection, then be sure to make an extremely detailed request down to the last pixel. For a person who simply crops their signature to make an avatar. You're very detail oriented.

It's not that I want it perfection, I just don't like the way this one turned out. I just don't fucking like it, I don't want to use it in my signature, I think it looks terrible. I don't have to explain why, it's not like there's something technical wrong that makes me hate it. I. JUST. DON'T. LIKE. IT.

to the OP, if you want good critique, I think you should post it in a gfx forum and not in a hacking forum. You'll improve faster, i think xD