User name Graphics. Worth Anything?

I did this for someone on gaia, they paid me like 4k, i thought that was more than enough.
Any good?

(art-no is there username)

not really. you just followed a tutorial you found here. it's too plain. add some other elements to it.

Doesn't look too great bevels are ew and lacks blending.

I personally liked it. It is by no means the complex beauty some signatures are, but it has a kind of mellowed out feel to it which I don't see in a lot of digital art. One of the things that I would do is spruce up the background, though starry is better than just plain black, adding a little color and complexity to the background would definitely improve it